I know we both wanted to be married someday (Oh)
But sometimes life just don't work that way
Time goes by, but the feeling don't fade
No, it don't
So baby, forgive me for what I'm 'bout to say
I wish we would've kept it
'Cause even if we weren't meant to be
You'd still have a piece of me
Is that wrong
That I wish we would've kept it?
At least we could still share custody
And I'd still see you on the weekends
Instead of not at all
I wish we would've kept...
I wish we would've kept it
Maybe I'm just selfish
It was a grown-up decision that we both had to make
Looking back on it now, I think we did the right thing
Yeah
But I can't help to imagine what would happen if we had had it
Now you won't give me the time of day
Say, I wish we would've kept it
'Cause even if we weren't meant to be
You'd still have a piece of me
Is that wrong
That I wish we would've kept it? (Mm)
At least we could still share custody
And I'd still see you on the weekends
Instead of not at all
Swear I wish we would've kept it
Oh, oh, oh
I wish we would've kept it, yeah (Oh, Jesus)
Every day, you're in my mind rent-free
And every morning without you seems like it's too long, it's too long
So baby girl, sing along
Tell me that you wish we would've kept it
You'd still have a piece of me
Is that wrong
That I wish we would've kept it?
At least we could still share custody
And I'd still see you on the weekends
Instead of not at all
Wish we would've kept it
I wish we would've kept it
Wish we would've kept it
Maybe I'm just selfish
Instead, I wish we would've kept it
Wish we would've kept it, wish we would've kept it
Wish we would've kept it
