There she goes with a smile on her face Riding right next to you Goin' out to all those places You used to take me to Wearin' your jacket like it was her own I used to wear it so well Why on earth did I let you go If I hadn't I'd be with you still Call it jealousy, call me a fool But it's more than my eyes want to see 'Cause it should've been me With you tonight It should've been me There by your side Seein' you both is hard to believe 'Cause it should've been me Flashin' that ring in everyone's face The one I gave back last week I wonder if you're tellin' her things You used to whisper to me To say it's over don't work anymore 'Cause it's more than my heart wants to feel It should've been me With you tonight It should've been me There by your side Seein' you both is hard to believe 'Cause it should've been me She looks so satisfied So close to you that I Can't help but wonder why I said goodbye last night As tears drop from my eyes