He's tall, dark and caught my eye
In only seconds, I knew this guy
Would be a fairytale for me
He held the door when we first met
Talk was short but I can't forget the way he said my name

We had coffee for two just to find out the truth
Didn't know he was gonna talk about you

Why-y-y are all the good ones gone
When girls like me wanna come along?
You can try-y-y to pull him back to Alabama
But too bad your boyfriend's here with me
In Tennessee

Yesterday, his foot bumped mine
He didn't even apologize
He just looked up and smiled
You should see how close he gets
It's like he's going in for a kiss
Someday he won't miss

Y'all have history but we got chemistry
I'm not stealing him, he's stealing me

Why-y-y are all the good ones gone
When girls like me wanna come along?
You can try-y-y to pull him back to Alabama
But too bad your boyfriend's here with me
In Tennessee, yeah, yeah

In case you want some closure
I've got something to say
You might as well get over him
'Cause I'm his new baby

Why-y-y you coming back around
When your ex-boyfriend don't want you back now?
You can try-y-y to pull him back to Alabama
But too bad he's staying here with me
Too bad he's staying here with me
In Tennessee
Ooh

You can try to pull him back to 'Bama
Oh yeah, yeah
In Tennessee