Oh, Valentine He was yours when I thought he was mine He wiped your tears while I cried All night I think it's strange how you look nothing like me I'm the moon, you're the sun, and I'm blinded I thought I was his type Were you the exception or was I? I can't help but wonder Look through all your pictures I think I'm addicted Like knowing every little detail might fix it Oh, Valentine He was yours when I thought he was mine He wiped your tears while I cried All night Oh, I can't lie to you, Valentine I'm comparing the blue in our eyes Your hair shines redder than wine I can't get you off my mind Mmh, mmh, mmh, mmh-mmh (Oh, sweet Valentine) Mmh, mmh, mmh, mmh-mmh (Ooh) He was calling the both of us sweetheart And kissing us both in the same car The smell of your perfume's in his backseat long after you're gone I can't help but wonder Looking in the mirror Tell me what I'm missing Like if I looked more like you, I could fix it Fix him Oh, Valentine He was yours when I thought he was mine He wiped your tears while I cried All night Oh, I can't lie to you, Valentine I'm comparing the blue in our eyes Your hair shines redder than wine I can't get you off my mind Mmh, mmh, mmh, mmh-mmh (Oh, sweet Valentine) Mmh, mmh, mmh, mmh-mmh (I) Mmh, mmh, mmh, mmh-mmh (Oh, sweet Valentine) Mmh, mmh, mmh, mmh-mmh (I) Oh, Valentine I'm not writing you for a reply If you read this with him by your side I thought I'd tell you both goodbye