When the lights go out, darling, so do you
And I'm missin' makin' love the way we used to do
That old fire is gone, there's got to be a way to turn it back on
Why don't you try treatin' me like that very first night?
And love me like you've never had me
Think of me as a fantasy
Hold me like you've never known me
Make believe I'm still a mystery
Well, I've never understood how the magic slips away
Or how the sparkle of a diamond could ever fade
Let's start over again and treat each other like we did back then
Close your eyes and take me back to the very first night
And love me like you've never had me
Think of me as a fantasy
Hold me like you've never known me
Make believe I'm still a mystery
Love me like you've never had me
Think of me as a fantasy
Hold me like you've never known me
Make believe I'm still a mystery
Love me like you've never had me
Think of me as a fantasy
Hold me like you've never known me
Make believe I'm still a mystery
