Met a girl in the parking lot And all I did was say hello Her pepper spray made it rather hard For me to walk her home But I guess that's the way it goes Tell me again, was it love at first sight When I walked by and you caught my eye? Didn't you know love could shine this bright? Well, smile because you're the deer in headlights Met a girl with a graceful charm But when beauty met the beast he froze Got the sense I was not her type By the black eye and bloody nose But I guess that's the way it goes Tell me again, was it love at first sight When I walked by and you caught my eye? Didn't you know love could shine this bright? Well, smile because you're the deer in headlights It's suffocating to say But the female mystique takes my breath away So give me a smile or give me a sneer 'Cause I'm trying to guess here Tell me again, was it love at first sight When I walked by and you caught my eye? Didn't you know love could shine this bright? I'm sorry I ever tried, you're the deer in headlights Tell me again, was it love at first sight When I walked by and you caught my eye? Didn't you know love could shine this bright? If life was a game you would never play nice If love was a beam, you'd be blind in both eyes Put your sunglasses on 'Cause you're the deer in the headlights You're the deer in the headlights You're the deer in the headlights