My arms were around her My eyes were aglow The moment was tender The music was low But while we were dancing I think you should know I was telling her about you She kept coming closer The magic was there She wore an expression That made people stare It looked so romantic But, darling, I swear I was telling her about you When you passed by And caught my eye You didn't say a word You turned about And walked right out And the silence Was the loudest I ever heard Come back to me, darling I must make you see That things aren't always What they seem to be The girl in my arms Meant nothing to me I was telling her about you I was telling her about you Come back to me, darling I must make you see That things aren't always What they seem to be The girl in my arms Meant nothing to me I was telling her about you I was telling her I love you