Every day it hurts me more and more
Can't walk away, I should have long before
Can't understand why I love that man
He's just an average guy, why do I wonder why?

I don't know why I love that guy (I don't know why)
I don't know why I do
I don't know why I need that guy (I don't know why)
But God, I wish I knew

Season to season and time after time
Love with no reason keeps tearing up my mind
Can't understand why I love that man
He's just an average guy, why do I wonder why?

I don't know why I love that guy (I don't know why)
I don't know why I do
I don't know why I need that guy (I don't know why)
But God, I wish I knew

Yes, I do, he knows it too
Yes, I do, I know he knows it too
Why, oh, why

I don't know why I love that guy (I don't know why)
I don't know why I do
I don't know why I need that guy (I don't know why)
But God, I wish I knew

I don't know why I love that guy (I don't know why)
I don't know why I do
I don't know why I need that guy (I don't know why)
But God, I wish I knew

I don't know why I love that guy (I don't know why)
I don't know why I do
I don't know why I need that guy (I don't know why)
But God, I wish I knew