You and I A story from another time About a soul caught in between And a love unknown to me Saw me standing by the sea Watched the waves wash over me They played Dancing in the Moonlight It was all there ever was And I tried and I tried And I told you yes until we die Something old and something new And a promise to be true, but I lied Nightingale, the truth was just too hard to tell I wish you'd never made me feel These tears pouring over me Dreamed about an open sky One that only youth could find And it was bright and it was new It was perfect just like you And I tried and I tried And I told you yes until we die Something old and something new And a promise to be true And I tried and I tried And I told you yes until we die Something old and something new And a promise to be true Yes, I lied, yes, I lied