Tell us a story, Billy I'll get another big log for the fire Tell us a story, Billy With tricks and spells and mad desire I know you got a story to make our laughter roar Doesn't matter that we've heard that tale a hundred times or more! Tell us a story, sweet William A great long story Tell us a story, Rachel Of the man tied to the mast Tell us a story, Rachel How the sirens sang in vain as his ship passed Remember that old shepherd who saved a royal babe That babe became a man and his own father slayed Tell us a story, Rachel A great long story That bitter wind keeps howling outside our creaking door But our roof is snug and tight and we have enough in store And even if soon this old world is giving up the ghost Well, I don't mind 'cause I'm right here with the ones I love the most Tell us a story, one more A great long story