Power in your eyes Strong on the outside Face like you made to be paid for your time Smooth just like a gangster Sharper than a pencil Swept me off of my feet, straight up to the sky And I fell for your disguise Caught up in the flashing light Oh, but I shoulda known Too good to be true Love ain't always what it seems I thought he was a superman, but he can't fly And he told me lies, why am I surprised? Oh, no superman, he the man of steel 'Cause he can't feel, no, nothin's real Superman, who's gonna save your soul When you ain't so super anymore? Looks, they gon' fade Parties overrated Boy, you already look like you so jaded Too much of the bottle Gettin' you in trouble What happened to a man like you thought you'd be brave? But you're livin' for the nights Caught up in the flashing lights Oh, but I shoulda known Too good to be true Love ain't always what it seems I thought he was a superman, but he can't fly And he told me lies, why am I surprised? Oh, no superman, he the man of steel 'Cause he can't feel, no, nothin's real Superman, who's gonna save your soul When you ain't so super anymore? But I shoulda known I shoulda, I shoulda, I shoulda known Oh, but I shoulda known Too good to be true Love ain't always what it seems I thought he was a superman, but he can't fly And he told me lies, why am I surprised? Oh, no superman, he the man of steel 'Cause he can't feel, no, nothin's real I thought he was a superman, but he can't fly And he told me lies, why am I surprised? Oh, no superman, he the man of steel 'Cause he can't feel, no, nothin's real Superman, who's gonna save your soul When you ain't so super anymore?