Left as five, returned as one 
Searching for bounty 
Their findings are plentiful 
Greedily, he wants all for himself 

He kills the others in their sleep 
Low on food, or perhaps a twisted fetish 
He eats their remains, 
Then blames the four men's death 
On nature 

On weather and wolves 
Bodies supposedly maimed 
By wild scavengers 
But skeptics want more proof 
Of how they died 

Not believing 
The possible 
Anthropophagus 
All are exhumed 
For more research 

Studies on the skeletal corpses 
Tell a very different story 
Butcher-like cuts on bone 
Skulls fractures from hatchet wounds 

[Repeat] 

On weather and wolves 
Bodies supposedly maimed 
By wild scavengers 
But skeptics want more proof 
Of how they died 

Blows and cuts 
To consistent between them 
No animals could have left these marks 
Found guilty of the murders 
And sentenced to death 
The first cannibal 
Caught with forensic science